N. Vizcaya’s ‘luxury buses’ draw flak

BAYOMBONG, Nueva Vizcaya–Officials and residents here denounced the alleged anomalous purchase by the provincial government of two brand new luxury buses worth P10.2 million, at a time when the country was suffering from severe food crisis and high power rates.

Board member Patricio Dumlao Jr. said the “questionable” purchase of a new 45-seater and a 25-seater Hyundai buses was made without the required public bidding, raising suspicion that this could be another graft-ridden deal entered into by unscrupulous provincial officials.

“This is highly anomalous because the province had to buy from a Korean supplier through direct purchase, when there are many other suppliers in the country that could have provided the same vehicles, maybe at less cost to the government,” Dumlao said.

He expressed dismay that instead of addressing the national concerns of food sufficiency, rising cost of basic commodities and electricity, the province has been more concerned about spending on their luxuries.

Documents obtained by this writer stated that the buses–a 45-seater Hyundai Universe model 2008 worth P6.3 million and a 25-seater Hyundai County model 2008 worth P2.7 million–feature “full basic functions” and are equipped with DVD players with monitor and a refrigerator.

Residents were also irked over what to them was another display of “wanton extravagance” by the provincial government, which has engaged in a spending spree on sports utility vehicles (SUVs) for its officials.

“The provincial government is so desperately trying to collect taxes but at the same time it is wasting taxpayers’ money on less important expenditures,” tricycle driver Armand Asuncion, 46, said, referring to the brewing controversy over quarry taxes between the province and a foreign mining firm.

Bayombong resident Sonia Capistrano, 35, a mother of three, said the province could have used the funds to help pay for the electricity bills in public elementary schools, a burden being passed on to pupils’ parents for years now.

On Wednesday, the provincial board approved a resolution authorizing Gov. Luisa Cuaresma to purchase the luxury buses on direct importation, upon request of the bids and awards committee which earlier declared a “failed bidding”.

Dumlao said it was “ridiculous” that while the BAC was still asking for an authorization for the governor, the buses have been shipped to the country and are ready to be delivered, stored at a shop in Quezon City.

In August 2007, the provincial board earmarked P9 million for the purchase of two air-conditioned buses supposedly for the province’s use during educational tours, seminars and out-of-town trainings and conferences.

But instead of conducting a public bidding, the province’s bids and awards committee (BAC) on April 15, declared a failure of bidding and picked Shin Heung Corp. of Seoul, South Korea as “exclusive dealer”, Dumlao said.

No public bidding, however, was ever initiated, he added.

“If there was an honest-to-goodness publication of the public bidding, a lot of dealers would have come to tender their bids. I wonder how Shin Heung came out of nowhere from Korea and offered to be a dealer,” he said.

Confronted during the board’s session on Wednesday, Tomas Garra, BAC chair, admitted he did not know the circumstances on how Shin Heung knew of Nueva Vizcaya’s need for two buses.

“They must have known through their contacts; afterwhich, they sent a letter to the governor. What I know is that one time I was invited to a meeting at the capitol, when I arrived at the venue, they (Shin Heung officials) were already there,” he said.

Dumlao expressed concern how anomalous deals in the province have become detrimental to the government, citing a P15-million bulldozer that was bought last year which broke down after only a few months’ use.

But because the buses are considered “luxury”, Dumlao said, the province cannot avail of tax exemption from importation that is granted by the local government code.

Garra said the provincial board may need to allocate P1.2 million more to cover the customs duties that must be paid by the province for the imported buses, bringing the total allocation to 10.2 million.


14 thoughts on “Anomalous

  1. oh that’s obscene! 10m is 1/3 of the 30m collectible from oceana! these people are really fond of luxurious cars huh. i remember the “talk of town” some years ago that some sb members got pahero for the mining to pass. it might not be exactly pahero (coz it’s too expensive) but sort of pahero-style car

  2. Yes, Karen. You must be referring to the purchase by the board members of SUVs, although these were the so-called imported second-hand cars. Others bought theirs from Port Irene in Cagayan. Our sources say other board members even made some money out of it.

    The money may not have come from the mining company directly, because it was sourced out of provincial government funds.

    It’s funny, because in 2005, the Sangguniang Panlalawigan passed, by a vote of 12-1 (although they wanted it to appear as unanimous, 13-0) a resolution endorsing the Didipio project.

    The endorsement was so obnoxious because the village council of Didipio and the town council of Kasibu voted against the project. A few hours before the SP voting, a number of board member dissidents spoke. After they had a closed door meeting at lunch time, they went for a 13-0.

    This is where SP got the label “Sugapa sa Pera”.

  3. money money makes man go funny..

    ..just like foreign mining companies who drool over other countries’ natural resources. 😀

  4. mel honey i thought that oceana gold was the corrupt one now u are talking about graft in the provincial government oh dear 30 million pisos for whom ? ganyan ang buhay

  5. Indeed tax exemption is not applicable since buses are NOT EARTH MOVING EQUIPMENTS but not luxury. I wonder why Board Member Dumlao knew that the bus is already somewhere in Quezon city, is he the secret dealer?

  6. Hey Mr Dumlao should prove that the bus is already “somewhere” in Quezon city or is he involved because he “knew” that OR is he again pretending to know everything and displays his arrogance that collapsed the image of his late parents ?

  7. I believe Board Member Dumlao’s motive for finding out that indeed, the buses are already in the country is to drive home the point that the vehicles are already awaiting delivery at the time when the bids and awards committee are still asking for authorization for the governor to purchase by direct importation. They declared a failure of bidding when they did not even attempt to have one. It stinks like a dead rat.

    It’s like a girl sweetly asking her father if she can now have a boyfriend but the father soon finds out that she’s already two months on the family way.

    If the father gets mad and becomes the first one to expose it, would you suspect the father to be the culprit? 😀

  8. mel honey in nsw they built the buses and then they found out they did not fulfill the requirements of the road transport authority so they then had to make many changes costing the tax payer mega bucks you think you have a mortgage on stupidity in politics na mate

  9. mel honey in nsw they built the buses and then they found out they did not fulfill the requirements of the road transport authority so they then had to make many changes costing the tax payer mega bucks you think you have a mortgage on stupidity in politics na mate

    There you go again–no punctuation. How am I supposed to respond? 😦

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s