N. Vizcaya execs bought car bling worth P.7M sans bidding

BAYOMBONG, Nueva Vizcaya–The provincial government has surreptitiously purchased car accessories worth almost P700,000 for 12 sports utility vehicles (SUVs) of board members here without following the law and procedures on government procurement, documents have revealed.

Records showed that as early June last year, members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan, who were each issued brand new Toyota Fortuner units, bought car accessories worth P682,823 without public bidding, in violation of Republic Act 9184 or the Government Procurement Reform Act.

A listing of the items bought also revealed that the board members had installed accessories on their vehicles not classified by law as necessary, but merely for ornament and comfort.

This Toyota Fortuner issued to Board Member Efren Quiben was installed with P102,000-worth of car accessories. Photo by Melvin Gascon
This Toyota Fortuner (license plate SHZ 299) issued to provincial board member Efren Quiben was installed with about P102,000-worth of car accessories, the most for any member of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan. It now features a carrier, chrome light covers, side mirror covers and door handle fittings, and LED lights. Inside the vehicle, there’s more. Photo by Melvin Gascon

The questioned purchases were made by the provincial government despite the graft case filed against Gov. Ruth Padilla and the 13 board members for the allegedly anomalous purchase of the 12 Fortuners, which cost the government some P18.5 million and were also bought without public bidding.

Sought for comment, Vice Gov. Epifanio Galima, the acting governor, confirmed the purchase of the accessories, but said he did not know anything about the transactions.

“When I came to know about it, I learned that the purchases have already been completed,” he said in an interview.

Sources privy to the transactions revealed that days after the 12 Toyota Fortuners were delivered to the provincial government last year, board members, allegedly through board member Efren Quiben, contracted a local supplier for the purchase of accessories.

The items were reportedly bought on credit with a local supplier, with Quiben, the SP appropriations chair, supposedly giving assurance of their payment.

“We can easily find funds for that,” he was quoted as having told other board members.

This writer sought Quiben for comment, but he said he did not want be interviewed.

“Just ask (the office of the governor) about it,” he said on July 6.


Among the items installed on the SUVs, the lists showed, included whole sets of leather seat covers; global positioning satellite (GPS) devices; roof carriers; chrome fittings for head, rear, and fog lights; stainless exhaust extensions; back up sensors with camera; and decorative license plate frames.

Documents obtained by this writer bared that Quiben’s vehicle received accessories worth P101,695.20, the most for any of the members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan.

The other SUVs issued to board members Victor Gines, Dolores Binwag, Donior Tidang, Filma Perez, Pepito Balgos, Santiago Dickson, Merlie Talingdan, Percival Primo Marcos, Nestor Sevillena, Johnny Liban and Flodemonte Gerdan were each installed with a uniform set of accessories worth P52,829.80.

In separate interviews, members of the provincial bids and awards committee (BAC) said the processing of the purchase was already underway, but claimed that they were unaware of any irregularity.

They all asked not to be named for fear of harassment from officials involved.

RA 9184 requires all government purchases shall be done through competitive bidding, with some exceptions using “alternative modes of procurement”.

However, sources in the provincial government, who asked not to be named for fear of reprisal, said the SP have split the purchases into two transactions, in an effort to evade the requirement of the law that would submit the deal to mandatory public bidding.

After the purchases were made to appear to have been split into two, these were already considered “small purchases”, allowing for each transaction to be carried out through the “shopping” method, sources said.

In this mode, the purchasing office simply solicits price quotations from three accredited suppliers, and the trader with the lowest quote gets the deal.

Payment for the first transaction has already been made, records showed, but allegedly with the use of falsified documents, with changes mainly on the dates to make it appear that the accessories were bought prior to their installation.

Records showed that the provincial government has already paid P367,071, through a Landbank of the Philippines check dated May 21, 2015. The funds for the payment were reportedly sourced from the SP’s allotment for motor vehicle repair and maintenance for 2015.

The payment of the second tranche is being processed by SP staff, it was revealed, but with the use of undated price quotation forms.#


5 thoughts on “DARK & DIRTY

  1. Parang pera naman nila yung pinag-gagasto, “Denial” “Ignorance” any public officials who uses such words as an excuse are not worthy to be on their offices; tumakbo ka pa na maging official kung BOBO ka pala. Hindi po hanap buhay yan.

  2. Letche! Nakita nyo hirap ng buhay ng mga kapwa nyo Vizcayanos during the campaign period, right? Habang nakasakay kayo sa mga SUVs na yan, yung mga taxpayers na nagtitinda at magsasaka, naglalakad pa papuntang palengke dahil sayang ang baryang ipapamasahe pa. tama nga, may mga taong matalino nga, magnanakaw naman… nagpaka-dalubhasa lang upang maging matalinong magnanakaw!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s